Skip to content

What to do when a client says your leads are junk

Example product scene: outcome stages for 36 Clearwater Plumbing leads: 6 won, 5 lost, 3 spam

Sooner or later a client tells you the leads are junk. The reflex is to defend the campaign or promise new targeting before the call ends. Both skip the question that settles it: what happened to each lead after it reached the client?

Why “the leads are junk” is often a follow-up problem

Before we built Attrival, we tracked this by hand. Every lead went into a shared sheet, and each client was asked to note what happened next. The clients who complained the loudest filled in the most rows, and their finished sheets rarely read like a list of spam. More often they showed real enquiries that had stalled somewhere in the client’s own follow-up.

That does not make every complaint wrong. Campaigns do attract spam, enquiries for the wrong service and people outside the area. The point is that a lead’s quality and what happened to it are two separate facts, and the review needs both before anyone touches the budget.

Agree with the client what counts as a bad lead

Agencies and clients often use “junk” for different things. Write the categories down together once, so the next review counts the same thing.

Five kinds of “bad” lead and who can fix each one
CategoryWhat it meansWho can fix it
Spam or fakeBots, test submissions, made-up names or numbers that never connect.The agency: form protection, placements and exclusions.
Wrong service or areaA real person asking for work the client doesn’t do, or from outside the area it serves.The agency: keywords, audiences, ad copy and location targeting.
DuplicateThe same person counted twice, for example a form fill and a phone call.Both sides: one record per person before anything is counted.
Never reachedA real enquiry nobody spoke to, however many attempts were made.The client: response time, number of attempts and channels used.
Reached, not readyA real enquiry that was contacted but hasn’t booked or bought yet.The client’s follow-up, helped by the agency’s offer and messaging.

Only the first three are lead-quality problems in the strict sense. The last two are real leads, and counting them as junk hides the point where the opportunity was lost.

Pull every lead from the period with its current stage

Take one month and list every lead the campaigns produced, not the handful the client remembers. For each one you need the source and campaign it came from and the stage the client’s CRM shows today.

  • Group leads by the date they arrived, so a lead that closes next month still counts toward the month it came in.
  • Keep leads with no recorded stage as their own group instead of guessing what happened.
  • Match CRM records to leads with an ID carried from the form, not by name, so two people called Chris Taylor never swap outcomes.

If the client still works from a spreadsheet rather than a CRM, the free client reporting template has the columns you need.

Read where the leads stall

Example month for a plumbing client: 36 leads by recorded stage (illustrative data)
Recorded stageLeadsWhat it suggests
Won6The campaigns are producing paid work.
Estimate sent5Real demand waiting on a decision, and worth a follow-up call.
Appointment set4Booked, but not quoted yet.
Contacted7Reached once, with no next step recorded.
No response6Never reached. Ask how many attempts were made, and how soon after the enquiry.
Lost5Chose another company or decided not to go ahead.
Marked spam3The only group that supports the complaint directly.

In this example, 3 of the 36 leads were spam. Another 13 were reached once or not at all. The conversation that helps this client is about those 13 people, not about the targeting.

Look at the same stages by campaign too. If one campaign carries most of the spam and out-of-area enquiries, that is a targeting fix, and now you can make it with evidence. Campaign attribution keeps each lead’s original campaign beside its recorded stage, and every campaign total opens to its own leads.

Decide what each side will change

On the agency’s side

  • Tighten targeting where wrong-service and out-of-area enquiries cluster.
  • Add form protection if spam arrives in bursts or from a single placement.
  • Add one qualifying question to the form when price shoppers dominate, and accept fewer leads in return.
  • Confirm every lead reaches the client with its source attached.

On the client’s side

  • Agree how quickly a new lead gets its first call, and who makes it.
  • Set how many attempts happen before a lead is marked as no response.
  • Update the stage in the CRM after every contact, so the next review can see it.

Make the stage review a monthly habit

The first review settles the argument. The reviews after it prevent the next one, as long as the stages stay current without someone chasing the client for updates.

Keeping stages current is the job a shared sheet does badly. Once the client’s CRM is connected, Attrival maps their own stage names to a common set a single time, so “Quote sent” can count as estimate sent, and each later stage change updates the lead beside its campaign. See how CRM outcome sync maps stages, or check which CRMs are on the connections page.

Start with one client and one month. The lead-to-outcome setup guide shows how to send a test lead and confirm its outcome comes back.

Keep reading about lead quality.

Show the next client where their leads stall.