Skip to content

ROAS vs ROI: which return belongs in a client report?

Example product scene: Summit Solar: 2 sales from 9 ad leads, return held for ad spend

ROAS and ROI both answer whether the ads paid off, but they divide different things. The same month can show a 7.5× return, a 12× return or a 130.8% ROI. None of these is a trick, but each answers a different question, and a report that mixes them loses the client’s trust the first time their accountant reads it.

The difference between ROAS and ROI

  • ROAS is revenue divided by ad spend. It ignores every cost except the ads.
  • ROI is profit divided by the total marketing investment. It subtracts the cost of doing the work and every marketing cost, your agency fee included.

ROAS tells you whether a campaign brings in more than it spends. ROI tells the owner whether the business is better off. Both are useful; they just shouldn’t share a label.

Platform ROAS is the platform’s estimate

The ROAS an ad account shows divides the conversion value it recorded by spend. For lead generation, that value is often a fixed amount per lead entered during setup, credited by the platform’s own attribution model. It is a useful steering signal inside the platform. It is not money the client received.

Signed work is not collected money

Dividing the value of won contracts by spend gets closer to reality, and it moves quickly, which clients like. But contracts get cancelled, shrink when the scope changes and are paid in stages. A contract-value return is a sales signal, not a revenue figure; counting contract value as revenue is one of the most common reporting mistakes.

Collected ROAS uses the payments actually received, minus refunds. It lags behind the contracts, and it is the first number an accountant will recognize.

Profit ROI needs every cost

ROI starts from the same collected revenue, subtracts the direct cost of the jobs and the full marketing investment, then divides by that investment.

ROI = (collected revenue − direct job costs − marketing investment) ÷ marketing investment × 100, where the marketing investment is ad spend plus agency fees plus any other marketing costs.

Leave out a cost and the result looks better than it is. That makes ROI the hardest return to report, and the most useful one when it is complete.

One month, four different returns

Example month for a home services client (illustrative data)
InputAmount
Ad spend$4,000
Conversion value in the ad platform$30,000
Won contract value$48,000
Payments collected, net of refunds$36,000
Direct job costs$21,000
Agency fee$2,500
The four returns calculated from the example month
ReturnCalculationResult
Platform ROAS$30,000 ÷ $4,0007.5×
Contract-value return$48,000 ÷ $4,00012×
Collected ROAS$36,000 ÷ $4,0009×
Profit ROI($36,000 − $21,000 − $6,500) ÷ $6,500 × 100130.8%

The 12× return and the 130.8% ROI describe the same month. A report that shows only the first leaves the client expecting a profit far larger than the one they made.

When each number belongs in the report

Where each return is useful and what to watch for
NumberUse it forWatch for
Platform ROASComparing campaigns inside one ad accountValues set in the platform, not paid by anyone
Contract-value returnShowing sales momentum before payments arriveCancellations and changes in scope
Collected ROASThe headline return once payments are inPayments that arrive after the cutoff
Profit ROIThe owner’s question: did the marketing pay for itself?Any missing cost makes it look too good

Leave a return blank until its inputs are complete

A missing return is better than a wrong one. Attrival counts only leads tied to an ad campaign, divides their recorded sold value by ad spend, and shows the result only when both share a currency and the ad data covers the whole period. Until then it says what is missing instead of filling the gap. See how return is calculated, or read what each amount in the report counts.

Ad spend comes from the ad account your agency assigns to each client. The connections page lists current platform availability.

Keep reading about returns.

Report the return your client’s accountant will recognize.