Skip to content

Cost per lead or cost per won job: which should clients judge?

Example product scene: campaign report: Spring roof 22 leads and 4 won jobs, Storm repair 15 and 2

Cost per lead is easy to measure and easy to improve, which is exactly the problem. Cheaper leads are often weaker leads, and a client who judges campaigns by cost per lead can end up paying more for every job they win.

Two formulas that answer two questions

  • Cost per lead = ad spend ÷ leads received. It measures how efficiently the ads produce enquiries.
  • Cost per won job = ad spend ÷ won jobs from those same leads. It measures what each sale cost in advertising.

Both use the same spend. The difference is everything that happens between an enquiry and a signed job, and most of it is in the client’s hands.

Why the cheaper lead can cost more

Two campaigns for the same roofing client in one month (illustrative data)
MeasureCampaign ACampaign B
Ad spend$4,000$3,600
Leads10040
Cost per lead$40$90
Won jobs46
Cost per won job$1,000$600

Judged by cost per lead, Campaign A looks better by more than half. Judged by cost per won job, Campaign B is 40% cheaper and brought in more work. Moving budget toward A would have looked like progress in the report and cost the client sales.

Count the wins that came from the same leads

Cost per won job only works when the wins come from the leads that spend produced. Take the leads submitted in the month and count the jobs those leads became, even when they sign the following month. Dividing this month’s spend by jobs signed this month mixes old leads with new spend.

Expect the figure to improve for a few weeks after the month closes, as late decisions come in. Say so in the report, and compare months only once both have had time to settle.

What sits between the two numbers

The gap between cost per lead and cost per won job is the client’s sales process: how many leads were reached, booked an appointment, received a quote and signed. Showing those stages explains a high cost per won job without blaming either side.

  • Contact rate: leads reached ÷ leads received.
  • Appointment rate: appointments set ÷ leads reached.
  • Close rate: won jobs ÷ quotes sent.

When most leads stop before the first conversation, the next fix is the client’s follow-up, as our article on junk-lead complaints explains.

When cost per won job misleads

  • Small numbers swing hard. Two wins instead of three raises the cost per won job by half, so look at a full quarter before cutting a campaign.
  • Jobs differ in size. A campaign that wins fewer, larger jobs can look expensive per job and still return more, so put won contract value per campaign beside it.
  • Long decisions lag. For clients whose buyers take months, the month-end figure is a first estimate.

How to show both in the monthly report

Lead with cost per won job and won contract value for each campaign, then show cost per lead and the stage counts underneath as the explanation. The client sees what each sale cost first, and the lead metrics stay visible as the levers.

Attrival calculates cost per captured lead and cost per won outcome from the same group of leads, using spend from the ad account assigned to the client and outcomes from their CRM. See how the client report lays them out, and how CRM outcome sync brings the wins back. The home services page shows the same idea for booked jobs.

More on judging campaigns.

Judge each campaign by the jobs it won.